Wednesday, February 8, 2017

Workflow Wednesday

Finding Cousins Using
Genetic Genealogy and Genealogical Research

Progress is being made in identifying my Lee ancestors, their descendants and extended family. My paternal grandmother was Alice Lee born in Wetumpka, Elmore County, Alabama on the 09 November 1887. Identifying the Lee family in which Alice Lee descended is important and I am working diligently to determine the correct line. So, these days’ genetic genealogy is on my mind. As I use this newest record to identify my ancestors and their families, educating myself in DNA testing is ongoing.
  
I have tested with all three DNA testing companies, and have tested my brother 67 Marker YDNA and autosomal – atDNA, two sisters, one paternal Lee cousin the YDNA 67 Marker and Autosomal – atDNA, one second cousin atDNA, two half cousins, a double first cousin, and a nephew. When I first became involved with DNA testing and learning how to interpret the results, I worked diligently learning all I could about genetic genealogy and using it with genealogical research.

Using YDNA test results, genealogical research, and family members with knowledge of the story, a family story was laid to rest. Matches from the autosomal DNA tests results and genealogical research for my paternal Meadows line has been successful in verifying that family line. Working with Edwards cousins, autosomal tests results, and genealogical research a common ancestor was identified, and the Edwards family has their rightful place in my family tree. These are just a few of the successes that I have experienced using DNA testing along with the fifteen years of genealogical research.

It was time to lay genetic genealogy aside for a while and gather information about others who were involved in the lives of my ancestors; that is, parents, grandparents, great-grandparents, great-great-grandparents, and so forth. I will do that by using cluster genealogy and get to know the family, extended family, friends, neighbors, and acquaintances of my direct line ancestors. Until I have information on those “other” people in my ancestors’ lives, using my atDNA results will be painstakingly slow; and even frustrating at times.

All of us who have researched for very long soon learned that our ancestors had siblings. I haven’t come across one ancestor in my research who was an only child. They had brothers, sisters, nieces, nephews, step-moms, step-dads, aunts, uncles, grandparents and the list goes on. By researching the family I really get to know them.

Genetic genealogy was put aside for about a year, and researching my maternal line Kuhn (Coon) family was a priority. That was fun while it lasted. I periodically checked the Family Tree DNA website to look at the YDNA results. Recently when I checked the account of my paternal Lee cousin. Low and behold, after almost three years there is a name that showed up. I was elated to learn he had one person on the 37 Marker YDNA with a genetic distance of 2. That piqued my interest in DNA testing again. That was one of those “aha” moments. The happy dance was on!

This Lee cousin tested in 2013 and he died January 2016. He would be happy to know he has helped in finding a new Lee cousin and furthering the research on the paternal Lee family line.  Having a Lee paternal cousin YDNA tested was very important in verifying my Lee line and the all-important paper trail.

Working on this project continues. ■

_________________________________________________

The Family Tree Guide to DNA Testing and Genetic Genealogy by Blaine T. Bettinger is a resource that is invaluable for genealogists and a book that is easy to read and understand. Other learning aids that I have used in research in addition to the one by Blaine T. Bettinger are: 
DNA & Genetic Genealogy:  An Introduction by Diahan Southard
Genetic Genealogy in Practice by Blaine T. Bettinger and Debbie Parker Wayne
NextGen Genealogy The DNA Connection by  David R. Dowell
Genetic Genealogy The Basics and Beyond by Emily D. Aulicino
Trace Your Roots with DNA by Megan Smolenyak Smolenyak and Ann Turner
The Stranger in My Genes by Bill Griffeth 
Family History in the Genes by Chris Pomery
The DNA Testing Advisor: Finding Family:  My Search for Roots and the Secrets in My DNA by Richard Hill
Forensic Genealogy by Colleen Fitzpatrick, Phd
Unlocking Your Genetic History by Thomas H. Shawker, M. D. 

Webinars for DNA that I have subscribed to are Legacy Family Tree Webinars:  http://familytreewebinars.com/
Family Tree DNA has webinars in the Learning Center about each test YDNA, Autosomal (atDNA), and Mitochondrial (mtDNA). https://www.familytreedna.com/learn/
Ancestry DNA also has webinars in the Learning Center.  https://support.ancestry.com/s/

Blogs that I follow for DNA:
The Genetic Genealogist by Blaine T. Bettinger http://thegeneticgenealogist.com/
DNAexplained - Genetic Genealogy by Roberta Estes https://dna-explained.com/
Kitty Cooper's Blog http://blog.kittycooper.com/
Your Genetic Genealogist CeCe Moore http://www.yourgeneticgenealogist.com/
The Legal Genealogist by Judy Russell https://www.legalgenealogist.com/blog/
Segmentology by Jim Bartlett  https://segmentology.org/ He doesn't blog often but when he does his articles are very good.
Cruwys News by Debbie Kennett https://cruwys.blogspot.com/

Monday, February 6, 2017

Monday's Musings

Jordan Lee from Richland County, South Carolina

Who are Jordan Lee’s parents? This is the question that I have been working to answer for a while. How does one identify the parents of an ancestor? What records are most helpful in linking a parent to a child? In genealogical research census records, birth and death records, and wills. That is the ideal genealogical solution when all these records are available. However, there are no ideal genealogical solutions when researching ancestors. Jordan’s parentage is unknown now; however, I have an assumption as to who he is, but that is a story for another day.

Researching my ancestors, both maternal and paternal, has lead me to one conclusion, they were farmers. I have drawn the conclusion from the 1850 to 1940 censuses from the occupation listed and available agriculture censuses. And those ancestors left a sprinkle of a paper trail. Neither Jordan Lee nor his son Benjamin left wills. So, there isn’t that document that states, “I leave to my beloved son Benjamin…” The records for Jordan Lee in Richland District, South Carolina are the censuses. There are some documents, other than censuses, that Jordan Lee are mentioned in Richland County, South Carolina.

Jordan Lee deceased is mentioned in Benjamin Hodge’s Revolutionary War pension that Zady Hodge applied for 13 October 1847 on behalf of the heirs of her mother, Nancy Hodge. He is mentioned in Benjamin Hodge’s administration papers. Jordan Lee was in the Richland County, South Carolina area until after the 1830 census, then he left South Carolina. By the taking of the 1840 Tallapoosa County, Alabama census was taken, he was living there in that county. On 1 June 1845 Jordan Lee purchased 40.14 acres of land that was a cash sale entry. Then in about1847 Jordan Lee died in Tallapoosa County, Alabama. There are also the Daughters of the American Revolution applications that have been submitted for patriot Benjamin Hodge to that organization for membership. Those applications have been proven and accepted with supporting documents for verification of Benjamin Hodge’s service and descendants.

A service record hasn’t been found for Jordan Lee. Why did Jordan Lee not serve in the military? I have searched for service records for him but haven’t found one. He could have served in the War of 1812 since he was about thirty-four years old. Or was he too old to serve in the War of 1812? When looking at his estimated birth year about 1778, possibly he was exempt from having to serve in the military.

As we all know who have researched for a while, genealogy is inexact and uncertain. We also know that there is a possibility that a relationship or information about an ancestor’s birth, death, marriage, or anything could be a little sketchy. The further back into the past you go the possibility of that happening is greater. Records were sometimes illegible – lack of formal writing skills. While you can never get around these things entirely, you can make sure your genealogy research is accurate and successful by using all available records. In the case of my Lee family there aren’t many online records available. However, I have searched for records for years hoping for more records for them to be placed online.

When using the available records, census records, I make sure the source of the information is recorded so that I will know where I found the information; and for others to know where I found the information. Genealogists know that census takers made mistakes when writing names, family members gave incorrect birth information and places of birth. So, we take that information and interpret it keeping in mind those possibilities. Is there information that you are not sure of that may be contradictory to previous information seen on another record? This information for your ancestor must be analyzed and resolved as to the accuracy of each record.

I believe from the records that I have for Jordan Lee, he is the father of Benjamin Lee and is a third great grandfather. This is soundly made based on the evidence that I have for him. However, if more records are found this conclusion may change. Sometimes, in genealogy research, we must take a leap of faith in our conclusions due to a lack of solid evidence. Is there a record that states Benjamin is the son of Jordan Lee? No, my assumptions are made with evidence where the record doesn’t outright state a family relationship or date, but can be inferred from the information that is there, information from other Lee family members, and the locations of the two men.

I will look for more evidence to back all this up. Records are being added online at a rapid pace. And I may eventually find that one record needed to link Benjamin to Jordan Lee. Once I find that record then I am at a point of being as sure as I can be about the accuracy of this line. Just because I haven’t found that record yet doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist. It may be in a courthouse waiting for me to come get it. Until then I will leave Jordan Lee and son Benjamin in their places in my family tree. And the search for Jordan's parentage is ongoing. His parents will one day have their rightful place in my family tree.

Saturday, February 4, 2017

Surname Saturday

The Lee Family from
Richland District, South Carolina

Who are the parents of Jordan Lee born circa 1778 probably in Richland, South Carolina? That is the question that has gone unanswered far too long. This family historian has utilized every research tip and trick that can be found in books, webinars, and numerous other resources to link Jordan Lee to parents; however, this may be one of those ancestors whose parentage may never be known. Because there are very few records left for the period that I am researching – 1778 to 1848 the Lee family has been a challenge to research  . The only records that I have to rely on are census records and land records. 

I have taken the 1800-1830 Richland County censuses and meticulously gone through page by page of those censuses looking for any Lee head of house. Jordan Lee is on the 1820-1830 Richland District, South Carolina censuses. His father-in-law Benjamin Hodge is living nearby on all those censuses. However, the only other Lee men were a Jesse Lee, Timothy Lee and on the 1800 Kershaw, South Carolina census was a Thomas Lee in the age 16-25 category. He was the only Lee person in that household on that census. Assuming Jordan Lee was born circa 1778 the age would be the right age for Jordan Lee; however, he supposedly married Lydia Hodge about 1805. So, where is Lydia? And they had children. The ages and dates just don't add up that he could be Jordan Lee a third great grandfather.

1810 Richland District, South Carolina

 1820 Richland District, South Carolina

 1830 Richland District, South Carolina

On the 1840 census, there is a Jourdan Lee living in Tallapoosa County, Alabama. Also, on the page before Jordan is Benj. Lee with one male under 5 and a male 20-30 age category. In the female age category, there was one under five and one in the 20-30 range. This would work for being Benjamin a son of Jordan and Lydia. Over to the right on the census a few pages is a B. Lee. The age category for him and those with the tick marks would work for Burrell the son of Jordan Lee. Jordan Lee acquired 40.14 acres of land 1 June 1845 in Tallapoosa County that was a cash sale entry. A few pages after Jordan Lee is William Pate living in the area. Burrell Lee married a Pate. This Pate may be connected to Burrell’s wife. With the circumstantial evidence on this census this is likely Jordan Lee, his two sons Benjamin and Burrell.

1840 Tallapoosa County, Alabama


I have taken the 1790 Fairfield District, South Carolina census and looked page by page for a Lee male head of house. I found Benjamin Hodge and Thomas Hodge on this census. I didn't find a Lee.

1790 Fairfield District, South Carolina


The 1790 Richland District, South Carolina census had one Lee a female Mary Lee as head of house. There were three males under 16 and four free white females with a total of household members seven. Looking at the age category for three males under 16, one of those males could be Jordan Lee. He was born circa 1778 probably in South Carolina.


The search for the parents of Jordan Lee yielded no results. But the genealogical quest continues. 



Thursday, February 2, 2017

Thankful Thursday

Estate Papers for the Estate of Thomas Hodge

The volunteers who go to courthouses and copy probate records and all kinds of records do a service for the genealogy community. I am thankful for all volunteers who give of their time to make it possible for me to sit at my computer at home and research my ancestors. Without this volunteer service I would not be as successful in researching my ancestors. Thank you volunteers for making this possible. 

The image below is an Administration paper from the estate of Thomas Hodge. I have researched the Hodge line enough to know that Benjamin Hodge born circa 1752 in Richland District, South Carolina married Nancy Rains. Benjamin served in the American Revolution. There have been several ladies to apply for membership into the Daughters of the American Revolution using Benjamin Hodge as their patriot. Therefore, I was able to accessthe information from the application on the Genealogical Research System of the DAR.org website. That is vital information in linking family members. 

I found in previous research that Benjamin Hodge was the father-in-law of a paternal third great grandfather Jordan Lee. Jordan married Lydia Hodge. While researching Jordan Lee and adding Lydia Hodge's name in the search box for spouse, records came up in the search results for Benjamin Hodge. When I looked through those records and the will for Benjamin, my daughter Lydia Lee was mentioned. That verified that she was the daughter of Benjamin Hodge and wife Nancy. Walla! I have the correct family. What a treasure that will was for this genealogist. 

This Administration paper for Thomas Hodge also has vital information.  It states that Thomas Hodge died intestate or he died without a will. So I need not look any further for a will for Thomas. Benjamin Hodge is the Administrator. There is a date on the paper; therefore this gives us an approximate death date. The place was Columbia, Richland District, South Carolina.

This is a good bit of information to further research on Thomas Hodge. 


There were sixteen pages to the estate papers for Thomas Hodge. The image below is from the sale papers. This shows a sale to Jordan Lee for one set of pewter plates for $2.50.  


When you look at page two of the sale, you will see the widow Anna there. Now I have the names of Benjamin Hodge's parents. In 2010 when I made a trip to the Family History Library in Salt Lake I found a record that showed Thomas Hodge  with Benjamin Hodge on the record, but I couldn't make the connection from son to father.

This was a goldmine of information in the estate papers. there were sixteen pages that included an administration bond signed by Benjamin Hodge, administration papers, account papers, petitions papers,  inventory, and sale papers,  Remember there wasn't a will because Thomas Hodge died without a will. 

This was all made possible because volunteers give their time to go to courthouses and repositories to make copies of records. Thank you volunteers for all that you do to make this possible for the genealogy community. 

Now,Thomas Hodge and Anna have their rightful place with their family. 
_________________________________________________
Source
Ancestry.com Database, Thomas Hodge, Richland, South Carolina, Wills, and Probate Records, 1670-1980, Estate Papers, Box 14, packages 326-350, 1799-1955. South Carolina County Court, Probate Place Richland, South Carolina. 



Wednesday, February 1, 2017

Wordless Wednesday

Kuhn Hunting

Recently I was on Archive.org and found the following book on that free digital library. Caspar Kuhn, his wife, and daughter are in the list of emigrants.





Tuesday, January 31, 2017

Tuesday’s Tip

What is a Pedigree Collapse and Endogamy? 

The Meadows Cousins

A family tree has pedigree collapse when one of your ancestors married a cousin. When cousins marry, there are only two grandparents instead of four. In my family line on the Meadows line William Meadows (a 3rd great grandfather) married his first cousin Jane Jean “Jincy” Meadows. William’s father was Isham Meadows, (Jr.). Jane Jean “Jincy’s” father was John Meadows brother of William. 

I first learned of William Meadows marrying his first cousin through Michal M. Farmer’s book The Daniel and Isham Meadows Family a revised edition of her 1976 book Daniel Meadows and His Descendants. You can check out the book here. 

Do you have colonial roots as I do? Then somewhere in your family tree you probably have pedigree collapse. According to Wikipedia in genealogy,  pedigree collapse describes how reproduction between two individuals who share an ancestor causes the number of distinct ancestors in the family tree of their offspring to be smaller than it could otherwise be. The offspring of two first cousins has at the most six great grandparents instead of the usual eight.

What is endogamy?  Endogamy is the practice of marrying within the limits of a certain community, culture, clan, or tribe. Sometimes, this is the result of tradition or religion, and other times it is a result of necessity. You can read about pedigree collapse here on the ISOGG website.

How many couples in your family tree are cousins? This would be something that you will need to pay closer attention to as you research your ancestors, and it is beneficial to know this as you look at your DNA matches. 

Monday, January 30, 2017

Mystery Monday

Caspar Kuhn and Life in the Old Country

Little is known about Caspar Kuhn’s family back home in the old country. There possibly is a paper trail for them, but that is a research plan for another time. Researching the Kuhn family here in America will keep me busy for a while.

Caspar left his homeland a young man and probably hadn’t been married for long to Anna Magdalena Mejer. They had an infant daughter when he and Anna Magdalena left their homeland to set out for a new adventure and a new life. Little did they know that their daughter wouldn’t make it to their new home in Carolina. Sometime during the trip to Carolina Baby Anna died and there were two additional children added to the Kuhn family – Margaret and Caspar, Jr.  However, their births were not listed in the Giessendanner list of births and marriages. Therefore, the conclusion is they were born in Germany or on board the ship to America. Anna isn’t listed in Caspar’s will and neither is Caspar Jr. however a granddaughter Elizabeth and Margaret are named in Caspar’s will.  I have not found any online records for Caspar Kuhn Jr. A trip to the South Carolina Archives will be in the future for this researcher.

When the Kuhn family arrived in Charles Town, South Carolina there were Caspar, Anna Magdalena, Margaret, and Caspar, Jr. They came into South Carolina about 1749.

Sometime after the arrival Caspar petitioned for a grant of land or fifty acres of land given to settlers to the area in this case South Carolina. Caspar was granted fifty acres for each individual, therefore he received two hundred acres of land; fifty acres per headright or head.

What was Caspar’s family like that he left behind in Switzerland? Were they a family of means? Did he have the finances to pay his way to America when he set sail for the colonies? When looking at Caspar’s arrival in South Carolina and then acquiring land one could assume that he had some knowledge of how to do business. What family life was like back in the old country is a mystery and one that is worthy of being solved. Perhaps one day a trip to Switzerland to research the Kuhn family line. Until then I will continue researching each of his descendants families to learn about them.